Year — Winner (Score) — Site

2026 — 7 p.m. Thursday — Geneva

2025 — Ohio (30-7) — Salem

2024 — Ohio (28-10) — Geneva

2023 — Pennsylvania (47-30) — Salem

2022 — Ohio (35-28) — Geneva

2021 — Pennsylvania (20-17) — East Liverpool

2020 — Game canceled due to coronavirus

2019 — Pennsylvania (21-0) — Geneva

2018 — Ohio (22-20) — Salem

2017 — Ohio (21-20) — Geneva

2016 — Ohio (10-7) — Springfield

2015 — Pennsylvania (34-20) — Geneva

2014 — Pennsylvania (24-7) — Springfield

2013 — Pennsylvania (25-22) — Geneva

2012 — Ohio (19-7) — Springfield

2011 — Pennsylvania (17-10 OT) — Geneva

2010 — Pennsylvania (38-8) — West Branch

2009 — Pennsylvania (24-12) — Geneva

2008 — Ohio (14-8) — West Branch

2007 — Pennsylvania (27-13) — Geneva

2006 — Ohio (27-7) — West Branch

2005 — Ohio (26-14) — Geneva

2004 — Pennsylvania (14-7) — Salem

2003 — Pennsylvania (26-6) — Geneva

2002 — Pennsylvania (21-17) — Salem

2001 — Pennsylvania (17-13) — Geneva

2000 — Ohio (25-18) — Wellsville

1999 — Pennsylvania (28-0) — Geneva

1998 — Pennsylvania (21-16) — Wellsville

1997 — Pennsylvania (13-6) — Geneva

1996 — Pennsylvania (27-6) — Wellsville

1995 — Ohio (24-12) — Geneva

1994 — Ohio (7-6) — Beaver Local

1993 — Pennsylvania (27-12) — Geneva

1992 — Ohio (14-7) — Salem

1991 — Pennsylvania (32-19) — Geneva

1990 — Pennsylvania (20-9) — East Liverpool

1989 — Pennsylvania (34-0) — Geneva

1988 — Pennsylvania (52-21) — West Branch

1987 — Pennsylvania (20-7) — Geneva

1986 — Pennsylvania (48-9) — Columbiana

1985 — Ohio (19-14) — Geneva

1984 — Pennsylvania (8-7) — Salem

1983 — Pennsylvania (15-6) — Geneva

1982 — Pennsylvania (28-13) — Salem

1981 — Ohio (21-14) — Geneva

1980 — Pennsylvania (21-7) — East Liverpool

Series record: Pennsylvania 29, Ohio 16 (one cancellation).