DMV probe, property deed charges push State Auditor Hunt to brink of impeachment
Trending
CHARESTON - Gov. Patrick Morrisey said Tuesday he told the West Virginia Division of Motor Vehicles to refer additional possible violations of state and federal law by State Auditor Mark Hunt to authorities and he will work with the House of Delegates toward impeachment.
In a press release and following a press conference Tuesday morning in Bridgeport, Morrisey said he directed DMV Commissioner Everett Frazier to refer findings from a months-long investigation of a used car dealership owned by Hunt and David Cole, his co-chief of staff, to U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia Moore Capito.
"As your governor, I believe I have a duty to preserve the public integrity of the state and her officials," Morrisey said. "And based upon what we’ve uncovered here, it was my duty to refer this matter to federal authorities for further investigation and potential criminal prosecution."
According to business records filed with the Secretary of State's Office, Hunt and Cole are partners in After Hours Used Auto LLC, a used car dealership registered on July 10, 2024, three months after Hunt, a former Republican state senator and Democratic member of the House of Delegates, won the Republican primary for state auditor.
Morrisey said the DMV began an investigation into After Hours Used Cars following a consumer complaint lodged against the dealership. During that investigation, Morrisey said, the DMV discovered what he called "anomalies" in the dealership's paperwork with the agency that possibly violate both state and federal law, including tax laws. The DMV suspended After Hours Used Auto on Nov. 6.
"We’ve determined that the information meets the standard for referral to federal authorities for review and potential criminal and civil prosecution," Morrisey said. "I want to thank Commissioner Frazier and his team for taking quick action on this issue, bringing this matter to my attention, and for the work they’ve done so far in the investigation."
Morrisey's referral comes one day after Capito announced federal indictments in a separate matter against Hunt, Cole, two other employees of the State Auditor's Office and Robert Johns, a friend and business associate of Hunt's who also briefly worked in the auditor's office as special counsel last year.
Hunt faces a 10-count indictment, including one count each for personally signing nine delinquent property tax deeds last year on behalf of MAPA Inc., a real estate company owned by Patricia Johns, the wife of Robert Johns.
All nine deeds were executed past the 120-day statutory window mandated by West Virginia code and without a circuit court order. The deeds are also supposed to be signed by the deputy commissioner of delinquent and nonentered lands and not by the auditor, but only those nine deeds were signed by Hunt personally. One of the nine transferred properties Patricia Johns’ MAPA purchased had been owned by NAJ LLC, an entity listing Robert Johns as a member and organizer, also in violation of state code.
According to the indictments, State Auditor's Office staff within the Land Division advised Hunt that the property deeds could not be legally executed on behalf of Johns due to required payments by MAPA not being made and the 120-day statutory deadline being missed. But Hunt ignored this advice, signing the deeds over to MAPA anyway, aided and abetted by Cole and Frederic Caudill, the general counsel for the State Auditor's Office, the indictments say.
The federal indictments allege that Hunt, Cole and Caudill "embezzled, stole, obtained by fraud" the nine delinquent property deeds, aiding and abetting Johns. Cole and Caudill face one additional charge each for allegedly lying to FBI agents last month during the course of the federal investigation.
Hunt, Cole and Marie Ann Johnson also face charges of defrauding taxpayers by the approval of timecards while the three were working on state time at Hunt's private law practice, where Cole served as office manager and Johnson worked as a paralegal.
According to a story published Saturday by West Virginia Watch, Hunt, Cole and Caleb Hanna, the other co-chief of staff at the State Auditor's Office, worked at After Hours Used Auto together. The dealership sits on land owned by Johns' NAJ LLC.
Morrisey also said Tuesday that he would support an impeachment inquiry by the House of Delegates after Speaker Roger Hanshaw, R-Clay, called on Hunt to resign or face possible impeachment proceedings when lawmakers gavel in for the 2027 regular session on Jan. 13.
"I intend to work with the speaker’s office to ensure that those proceedings can work as expeditiously as possible, and I’ll be reaching out to the speaker to talk and coordinate activities," Morrisey said. "I intend to work with the speaker on the timing of the House’s potential impeachment proceedings. And obviously, I remain flexible to work with the House leadership to make (sure) that happens as soon as possible."
If the House adopts articles of impeachment against Hunt, the 34-member state Senate would sit as a jury to consider the articles. A two-thirds vote - 23 senators - in favor of any article could mean Hunt's removal from office and disqualification from holding any future political offices.
In a statement Monday, Hunt maintained his innocence and said he will fight the charges and remain as auditor during the course of the criminal investigation. Both the state Republican and Democratic parties, State Treasurer Larry Pack, and multiple lawmakers have called on Hunt to resign before it gets to the point of an impeachment inquiry.
"In several media interviews last week, I made it clear that West Virginia law does not give our state auditor the authority to personally sign deeds for properties purchased at delinquent tax sales," said state Sen. Ryan Weld, R-Brooke. "The auditor disagreed and questioned my ability to read the law. It appears, however, that I was correct.
"Everyone charged is presumed innocent until proven guilty, but given the magnitude of these charges, Auditor Hunt cannot continue to lead an office entrusted with West Virginians' property and tax dollars," Weld continued. "He must resign immediately."
"The top official West Virginia trusts to catch fraud has been federally indicted for it," said Del. Kayla Young, D-Kanawha. "Corruption at the top poisons trust in all of government. ... Hunt spent the past few weeks shrugging off the law and calling himself 'the boss.' West Virginians deserve better. While innocence is presumed, Hunt is no longer fit to serve as our auditor. Mark Hunt should resign immediately."